Book Review Guidelines

Updated July 2016

Guidelines for Women in German Newsletter Book Reviews

The Women in German Newsletter publishes reviews of new books by WiG members.

Our goal is to inform WiG members about new publications by WiG members and foster a critical discussion about feminist scholarship in German Studies. Reviews should offer a brief summary of the book’s content and a critical evaluation of the work in the broader context of gender studies and feminist theory.

It is the author’s responsibility to bring or send a copy of their book to our annual conference where the book review editor will find a reviewer. Copies can also be mailed to the Book Review Editor:

Nicole Grewling
Department of Modern Languages
Washington College
300 Washington Avenue
Chestertown, MD 21620

Reviews are published once a year in the Summer issue of the Women in German Newsletter. They can also be accessed through the Newsletter archive on our website.

What to Include in the Review:

Possible questions might include: What is the theoretical and analytical framework? How does the book contribute to feminist theory and/or the field of gender studies? Does it offer an interdisciplinary and/or innovative perspective? Does it include a discussion of non-canonical works? What is its classroom potential? Is the book clearly written and does it live up to its claims?

Positive and negative comments should be supported by adequate but concise evidence, errors of fact should be mentioned, but lists of spelling or typographical errors should not be included in the review. Reviews are published in German and English.

If you have not written a book review before or would like more detailed information on how to write a book review, check the Women in German website, under book reviews (publications).

Submission:

Please e-mail your review to the book review editor, Nicole Grewling, at bookreviews@womeningerman.org (or ngrewling2 [at] washcoll.edu) no later than March 1, 2017. Send reviews as a Word document attachment (any version).

Length and Format:

1000 words MAXIMUM (complete text; excessively long reviews will be returned for revision), single spaced (also, please single space after periods). Also: 1-inch margins, 12pt. Times New Roman. No footnotes or lengthy quotes please.

The book's author/editor, title/subtitle, series/edition, place of publication, publisher, year, pages, and price (if known) must appear at the beginning of each book review. Example:

Westgate, Geoffrey. Strategies under Surveillance: Reading Irmtraud Morgner as a GDR Writer. Amsterdam/New York: Editions Rodopi, 2002. 276 pp. ISBN: 904201458X paperback, $47.00.

At the end of the review, please type your full name and affiliation as follows:

Martina Caspari, International School of Stuttgart

Please be advised that the editors of the journal may make minor changes to the text of the review. Such changes are usually made in the interest of clarity, style, consistency, or brevity, but will not affect the overall argument of the review. The edited review will be sent back to the author for final approval. Since the editors bear the final responsibility for the newsletter’s content, they must reserve the right to refuse (upon appropriate consultation with the reviewer) any review that is considered to be unsuitable or excessively tardy. 

Late Reviews:

Reviews that are late or require extensive editing may be returned or held for publication in the following year’s Newsletter. In the interest of timely information about new publications, please inform us if you are unable to complete your review on time, so that another reviewer can be found. If you fail to submit your review or submit it excessively tardy, you may be barred from reviewing futher books.

Graduate Students:

Please note a change in the WiG Newsletter’s policy regarding reviews by graduate students: only graduate students who are ABD are eligible to review a book for the Newsletter. In most cases, the book should be closely related to the student’s dissertation topic.

Copyright:

We also accept previously published reviews, if copyright is obtained by the author.

Nicole Grewling, Washington College, Book Review Editor, Women in German Newsletter

Jaclyn Kurash, University of Pittsburg, Co-Editor, Women in German Newsletter

Wonneken Wanske, Rhodes College, Co-Editor, Women in German Newsletter